Not sure about this. Will probably give it another episode... but did they give the "magic man" away by having him slip off the Sheriff's wedding band?I thought it was supposed to be a "who dun it" mystery like Harper's Island.... Who the shit is this Chloe person....
At least it was pretty gruesome, which is good

There was only one thing that stood out that I didn't like - how incompetent they made the little girl "earthcakes" and "killeded" WTF. Isn't she 6 or 7 years old?