Commenting as I watch... Thurr's no sound!? 

Paige: Didn't like it. I agree that it was totally the wrong song. Never mind her ugly outfit lol

Ashley:  She looks very nice Few pitch problems and a little shaky. She seems to be more of an upbeat singer, not too sure why she picked such a depressing song especially since it didn't really show off her voice. Can see her making it to the next week, though.

Janell: Hart is perfect for her voice, not sure if this is the best song out of the Hart vault to pick. Tiny bit off key and a bit shaky again. Agreed 100% with Randy and Simon. Should have picked a different Hart song haha

Lilly: lol @ song. Smooth choice, actually, especially since most people will pick more current songs - too easy to compare. She's still one of my favorites!!!  She better make Top 12!!

Katelyn: What the balls is she wearing? Possibly the best sounding vocal thus far, great arrangement. Disagree, didn't feel like she needs work except for the weird outfit.

Haeley: Still don't think she's a good singer. Agreed with Simon that it was painful. She's just so screechy lol

Lacey: FAIL. F.A.I.L. You've got a second chance and that's what you pick? She better be facepalming right now.

Michelle: LOL Awesome video package. haha She's like Alecia Keyseseses twin. Hard song to sing. I think she didn't too bad. She knew she couldn't sing it as high as Alecia and she didn't try to, which saved her performance for me.

Didi: Her voice is really nice. I don't understand how he can say that several of them sound the same... when he picked them LOL

Siobhan: Lights are on but nobody's home? lol Debbie Downer of a song to choose but if she gets through, I do see her being a dark horse. She's... kinda creepy.

Crystal: Woot! She's my favorite female aside from Lilly. Top 12!! Top 12!!

Katie: Weird song the pick, but she pulled it off. Agreed with the panel, needs a more upbeat song!

Paige - I thought she slaughtered that.

Ashley - I honestly don't even remember he performing tonight 

Janell - I was doing some psychology, so yeah... I don't remember her either

Lilly - I think she did a good job. Pretty cool that she lived in her car for a while too.

Katelyn - I thought she did a good job too... I agree with Randy. I liked her hair and all of that shit.

Haeley - You were right all along... She can't sing. I must have been on crack or something. She made my ears bleed tonight.

Lacey - She kinda freaked me out. For some reason I picture her covered in pigs blood, and shouting war cries?

Michelle - I liked her performance... I thought they were rather hard on her.

Didi - Love her voice... She's my fav femme.

Shinobi - Great ninja style, and great graphics. Level 3 was quite difficult though. I liked the song she went with, BUT I liked the original, not her version... It was the wrong choice for her.

Crystal - I love Alanis, and I thought this missy did a goot job with that song. I could listen to it again and again and one more time... Then I'd take a short nap, and give it another listen or two... but no more until maybe the next day.

Katie - Don't really remember her.

LOL I love your assessment, D! So true, so true. It was a very weak show yet they keep saying that the girls are "so strong".  
Awe boo! Andrew's singing last lol Stupid marketing!!

Todrick: I actually like him. He seems so familiar!!?? Oo for some reason I quite like this - except for the weird dancing. ...What? I didn't think that he murdered it?   It wasn't the *best* version of that song, but it wasn't the worst.

Aaron: This guy is soo geeky, you just have to like him LOL He's got a really nice voice. A bit shaky performance. Why do they pick boring songs to sing? He doesn't seem to be lacking in self confidence? LOL oh now he's tearing up...

Jermaine: This is shit. Hockey time.

Tim: I'd hate to be him. All eyes are on him just because he's the replacement. Let's see how he SCOOOOOOOOOORES!!!!!!! 6-1!!! (that was super nice!!) handles the pressure! Uhh... LOL Didn't like it. /tries to stop laughing. They should have picked Thaddeus instead of this guy.

Joe: He is sooo cute. He's singing it well but why do they always pick boring songs. No one ever remembers them. He needs to be singing some Enrique. Honestly.

Tyler: Screams douchebag, but at least he did something interesting and somewhat memorable. Of course he'd pick something safe and stuck to the 70s but that might be a good strategy to get passed this round. I agree with the judges, they hit the nail on the head. AND COPIED WHAT I SAID.

Lee: For a guy who was hesitant to audition!? He did fairly good! A few pitch problems but it was still really enjoyable. Interesting song to pick with that weird arrangement. Wonder why he picked it. Agreed with Randy, KoL would be perfect for him. Hope he makes it to the top 12!!

John: NOOOO! He's voice isn't low enough for that. Boring Boo. He was one of my favorites from the auditions. I wouldn't be surprised if he makes it to next week tho *fingers crossed*

Michael: So on the fence with him. One song, I love him. The next I just don't know... and with this one I just don't know. He sings it well but it just sounds weird coming from him. haha I do agree that if the others were stronger, this wouldn't have seemed as good.

Alex: Got better towards the end. The beginning was weird and downright awkward lol

Casey: I don't think that he's as good as Kara seems to think but this wasn't that bad. It wasn't bad at all. I think most of his sex appeal comes from Smith on Sex and the City. Now GTFO and bring on Andrew.

Andrew: It doesn't matter what he sings, he's going to go far. It wasn't THAT bad, but it honestly doesn't matter haha

Sheesh, listening to them doing to recap.. they were really horrible. Lee doesn't sound bad at all in comparison to the ones who went before him. Either does John. Hopefully that helps them.

The four eliminated tomorrow: Lacey, Paige, Jermaine and maybe Alex or Tim?

Yeah I agree... Most of them sounded like crap on the recap.

Todrick: I thought it was rather cool that he changed the hell out of that song. His singing didn't blow me away or anything, but I think he's creative, AND THAT'S A GOOD THING. The judges don't have a clue what they want. One second they want you to make it your own, and the next minute they want you to basically do it the same... Pfffffffff

Aaron: I don't know... I liked his voice, but he seemed a little nervous. I agree with Simon. He doesn't realize that he belongs to be there. Yet.

Jermaine: I agree... I hated that song. Simon was right. A 50 year old would probably request it.

Tim: Tim sucked ballz. He completely slaughtered that song, and if I'm One Republic, I hunt this dude down and make him pay for crapping on their song like that.

Joe: The song was crap, and he went down a notch in the singing department (in my books) Better turn it around, Joey.

Tyler: lol this guy was so comfortable up there! I have a feeling Tim drugged this guy or something... He definitely bonged up or something before he did this performance... I kinda like this Tyler guy, but he definitely has sort or mental problem

Lee: Completely loved Lee's performance tonight. I disagree with everyone but Simon.

John: Boring as crap. Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz!!!!

Michael: I like him, but I don't think he's good enough to win. Tonight I thought he was decent... But he's not good enough to win the competition IMO.

Alex: I really like his voice... It's rather unique IMO. Once he becomes a little more comfortable, I think he'll be something special.

Casey: I hope he's still on the show next week... So Kara can rape him on the stage. Put your hormones away, lady! Anyway, he's decent... I don't know what else to say... He kinda reminds me of a less cool/pansy singing version of Sawyer from Lost. Survive an airplane crash, survive getting shot, being attacked by a shark, being attacked by a smoke monster, 4,000 explosions, AND survive the Others and then we'll talk... MAYBE.

Andrew: I liked it! And again, the judges are like... Blah blah blah blah yadda yadda yada wiggity wang slang. Andrew is still my fav. He reminds me of someone.

Hmm. I checked DialIdol and it had Katie Stevens with the most female votes, Crystal second with Lilly coming in third. I'm actually shocked as to who they have as the bottom two lowest votes for the ladies.

For the men, of course Andrew is in the lead, Casey in second and Michael Lynche in third. The bottom two aren't surprising at all... but I'm surprised where Tim and Alex placed.

According to DialIdol, the four who should be cut are
[spoiler] Katelyn Epperly and Siobhan are the lowest two females, with Jermaine and Joe the lowest for the men[/spoiler]

Hopefully it's too early to tell because the female thing seems off. I'll check back tomorrow afternoon

Holy shit. Didn't see that coming at all LOL I don't even know what to say... How did Jermaine survive that? I just... America is stupid.

Can't believe Tim is still there. Just... Wow.